what about your TPM edit ?
It is a work-in-progress for sure. Work has commenced on it since my last posts, but that project is in a whole other category and immensely time consuming and draining. I don’t even think of it as “fanediting”, more like “remaking”. The plans I have for that edit is also beyond the scope of some of the things I am able to do as of right now.
The Inquisitor giving a speech about Jedi compassion is cartoon-level villainy. The official narrative of the Empire is that it is hunting down the Jedi because they betrayed the Republic, not because they are too kind. This isn’t how governments (even evil ones) spread propaganda about their enemies.
Agree a little bit. I think we will have to keep the opening dialogue to not make their appearance feel flat and empty. And I also think Reeva is the biggest problem, not the Grand Inquisitor.
They’ve leaned way too hard into making Obi-Wan look sad, pathetic, and lonely. I think it would actually be more powerful (and, in a way, more sad) if Obi-Wan retained a degree of optimism in the face of such a dire and hopeless situation. They are doing to Obi-Wan what they did to Luke in TLJ, but it happens to be even less fitting for Obi-Wan’s character, who is typically even more stoic and steadfast than Luke.
Agreed. This has been mentioned by a few other people in the thread as well, and I do agree. It does feel predictable and boring at this point.
Leia’s character is just bad. Sure, Leia was sharp as a tack in the original trilogy, but she didn’t have genius level psycho-analytical skills. Just let her be a damn kid here.
I like her character except for her analysis of every grown-up encounter. So yes, agreed.
I actually really like what you did with the Anakin scene. Maybe have the transitions be faster, like an eye blinking. They are after all looking at each other, …sorta (or at least sensing each other).
Thank you. I will probably revisit the scene some more as the edit go further ahead.