logo Sign In

Post #1484576

Author
Servii
Parent topic
Unpopular Opinion Thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1484576/action/topic#1484576
Date created
16-May-2022, 11:15 AM

NeverarGreat said:

While yes, a desert can be striking and beautiful, there is at least a thematic reason why Tatooine is so drab in Star Wars, that being Luke’s angst at his backwater nothing planet.

I’d like to see a desert planet in Star Wars that actually is stunning. Pasaana tries to do this but it isn’t fully there.

Tatooine does serve that thematic purpose, but it also acts as a “land of mystery,” like when the droids are wandering across it. That’s something that’s been missing from Tatooine for a while, that sense of "alien"ness and mystery. And I’d argue that Tatooine wasn’t visually drab for the most part in the films.

This isn’t a landscape example, but one comparison that comes to mind is the Cantina. In the movie, it’s filed with wacky/scary aliens, there’s Benny Hill-style (but still kinda alien-sounding) music playing, and the room is lit with warm lighting. In The Mandalorian, the Cantina is coldly lit, quiet, and mostly empty.