logo Sign In

Post #148185

Author
starkiller
Parent topic
If George had only changed Special effects for the SE and DVD, would people have complained as much?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/148185/action/topic#148185
Date created
16-Oct-2005, 2:46 PM
I detest:
- Han Shot First (and I have the PvP T-Shirt to prove it)
- Replacing Sebastian Shaw
- 97 Jabba scene
- Redone ROTJ ending
- Changing Boba Fett's voice (why doesn't George just change the credits to say Morrison instead of Bulloch...Half the time it was Bulloch anyways, so what difference does it make.)

I do not like, but tolerate:
- 03 Jabba scene (at least Jabba looks better)
- Jedi Rocks

Indifferent:
- Approach into Mos Eisley
- New Emperor in ESB (BUT I do NOT like the changed lines. Return the lines to how they were and it would be alright)

Approve:
- CGI upgrades to most of the Special Effects (I don't think I could handle the original Jabba's palace song with the new CGI Sy Snootles).
- Biggs scene (ever since I was a little kid it bothered me. Luke just arrives on Yavin 4, he's thrust into a combat situation fairly quickly, but he's comfortable with this other pilot that he "just met", calling him by his first name and everything. Adding the Biggs scene gives us a tiny intro so we know why. Beyond that, I wouldn't mind it if Lucas reintegrated the scenes with Biggs at the beginning of the movie.)