logo Sign In

Post #1478890

Author
AspiringCreator
Parent topic
FanEdit Reviews - Post Your Reviews Here
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1478890/action/topic#1478890
Date created
6-Apr-2022, 9:51 PM

krausfadr said:

AspiringCreator thanks for the review (I still need to read the whole thing). 5.5 stars is definitely fair as this was one of my first edits. I’m honored someone would take the time to write such a detailed review. Maybe one day I will restart this from scratch and get rid of the whole Corellia plot. But first I want to see what Spence does. Hopefully his will be definitive for me.

EDIT: read the whole thing now and thanks again. Very fair critique. In later revisions of the edit all audio transitions got moved into wrong positions after having to try and replace source files in a dying Premiere project. They had to each be manually fixed and perhaps that contributed to some of what you didn’t like. If I do anything else on TROS it would be starting anew in Resolve.

I hope I wasn’t too harsh. I tried to be as honest as possible while making sure not to discredit the effort that went into it. Also if you do go back to it? That would be awesome but if you don’t that’s also great. The fact you put in the effort to taking this finished movie and edited it into something so different is insanely cool and some of the stuff you did with it blows my mind.