logo Sign In

Post #146845

Author
Mr Bungle
Parent topic
Darth Vader birth scene, good or bad choice?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/146845/action/topic#146845
Date created
10-Oct-2005, 3:27 AM
I think people would have been mega pissed off with Lucas if Vader in the famous suit didnt appear, I cant imagine it really crossing Lucas mind about preserving the surprise as he sees as one big story and people would not be pleased with Anakin just to be left for dead and no proper conclusion..

I was suprised the way Anakin was christened as Vader by Palpatine as I expected it to happen after he was wearing the suit, one scene I may have a little grumble with is Palpatine saving Anakin it seemed slighty out for him to be bothered about him seeing as he is so evil and selfish,(how else could Lucas do it?)

I dont dislike the birth scenes and think the actual fitting up of the suit and Anakin having his robotic limbs done are good, now, I dont mind the "NOOOOOOOOO!"(it wasnt needed but oh well) and the Vader dialouge about Padme, and think Mcdiarmid was really good in the scene, I personally think a maybe better end to the movie would have been the Vader scene in the Destroyer not the Luke scene.

I also would have loved to see the him(suited Vader) in action but as we know Lucas sprang the surprise(to me) of (unsuited) Vader doing the business(maybe shown him actually killing a Jedi or two)
.