logo Sign In

Post #146787

Author
jabberdoo
Parent topic
***The "Darth Editous" Episode IV DVD Info and Feedback Thread*** - a partially "de-specialed" DVD
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/146787/action/topic#146787
Date created
10-Oct-2005, 3:37 AM
I just got my dvd and I'm amazed at the quality of work you did DE!! I think the best thing about this is all of your fixes are seamless. Meaning nothing you did sticks out like a sore thumb. (unlike ILMs work) I think this is the way the special editions should have been. Fix the poor special effects and all the misstakes/bad edits and polish up the movie. All anoyances have been removed and I'm thankfull. The only things I saw that bugged me just a bit. (and I'm REALLY nit picking)

1. Lukes lightsaber still looks green/white. Doesn't match other blue sabers especially Anakin's in ROTS which is the same saber.
2. The green R4 unit, looks weird only because a second before that R2 is all by himself with nothing close to him, then all the sudden there's this mysterious green R4. The only fix I could think would be to digitally cover the R4 with a Jawa or use another shot of R2 standing by himself. But that's just a personal opinion.
3. It looks like right after Greedo bites the dust you see the furry 4 eyed monster in suspenders it looks like there's a purple bar in the middle of the screen. Perhaps that was just me or my tv.

Other than that, this is perfect in every way and I applaud you for such an awesome job!!!