Sign In

Post #1465869

Author
Stromboli Bones
Parent topic
The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Edits (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1465869/action/topic#1465869
Date created
7-Jan-2022, 12:35 PM

Life has been busy but my Quality Rebuild is under way!

It’s a little more complicated than a simple “Find and Replace” of my source files, so that has taken some extra time to sort, but we’re cooking with gas, as they say.

I’m also toying with making a few small changes, outside of the usual Extra frame here, sloppy fade there, etc:

  • @TM2YC cut Blunt the Knives really cleanly in his edit and I’m thinking about doing it in a similar manner.
  • I’ve also considered reinstating most of the Mirkwood sequence. I trimmed it after some feedback, and received some more feedback suggesting to revert it, and I think i agree. I like the longer bit, it really let’s the confusion set in.
  • Reinstating Sauron’s eye showing up right before they enter Mirkwood and cutting it from Bilbo’s encounter with Smaug is probably a for-sure thing at this point. This will keep Sauron in the film but will lessen the relationship between him and the Ring.
  • Once I’m satisfied with these changes, I’m going to start working on an Episode 4.5 that contains the full High Fells/Dol Guldur subplot for the people who want to know what Gandalf was up to in between Episodes 4 and 5! This may prove a challenge as I myself don’t enjoy hardly any of that sequence, but I’ll do what I can!