Whatever is done, I quality of the posts should be judge more than quantity. I like the idea of having these titles to aim for. I think its fun. But I hate the trolls that do anything to obtain titles that they do not deserve. Perhaps it should be a combination. In order to obtain a title, have to have certain number of posts, been member for a certain amount of time, and then get nominated. And perhaps after the voting, Jay or a person or group of people he appoints will make the final call on whether to approve or override the vote. That would help prevent the "cliques" that Dayv fears.