logo Sign In

Post #1414785

Author
djonesed
Parent topic
The NumeralJoker/MechaSalesman 4K HDR Edits Megathread, Clips Previews, and Release Info
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1414785/action/topic#1414785
Date created
4-Mar-2021, 7:46 PM

i downloaded the 1080p version of Rebels and immediately noticed the image seemed unusually bright. a comparison with my blu-ray rips revealed not only a difference in brightness but also loss of detail.

blu-ray
blu-ray

NumeralJoker 1080p (notice the grass blades have almost entirely disappeared)
1080p

it’s especially noticeable on faces where it sometimes makes skin look like it’s literally glowing.
blu-ray
blu-ray2

NumeralJoker 1080p
1080p2

i don’t usually notice or look for this kind of thing but it was immediately apparent that the image looked off. idk if this is an unintended effect of your process converting to 4k and then back to 1080p or intentional, but i have to say i much prefer the original look. also, i proceeded to compare your clone wars 1080p version with the blu-ray and found similar brighness increase, though it didn’t seem as pronounced in the few shots i checked. unfortunately, i don’t have the equipment to enjoy your 4k hdr upscales which seem to be the primary goal of your project, so i understand if this isn’t worth addressing.