I’m not sure. The main issue is the puppet arm and the thing it throws. A Walker could hide some sins.

I’m basically gonna go back to the drawing board, start by content-filling the ball and wire which I’ve just learnt a new trick on how to do, then remask the puppet and try to clone over the fire bucket once the other parts look seemless.

I’m still pretty new to AE but this would be a nightmare cover job even for a pro I think. Basically because there is no symmetry to the backdrop so if you just clone it your eye would see the pattern.