PMed
Surprised you haven’t already found an edit you like before mine - there’s been dozens since 2014! But I can see what you mean, mine is one of the few 4-hour book accurate ones. Most people make 3 movies to 2 movies edits, or 3 movies to one short 2-3 hour movie, but there’s a nice middle ground in my opinion.
to be fairly honest, I saw the Tolkien edit back when it was pushed out, and just due to its state of release and some of the edits made, it felt like it could’ve been a lot more, and I dropped my search for a while after that due to nothing really catching my eye and the finding of Harmy’s Despecialized SW Trilogy lol. and to be perfectly honest, I really enjoyed this as a single movie. I finished it at 4am and I have to say I absolutely love it! its definitely my go to for a book accurate film. its what I was hoping and expecting the Tolkien Edit to be, and so much more. thank you again for all your hard work because you did a fantastic job. 😃