For me it is the best Disney era film, but it’s not like the bar is super high.
I really want to know how the film went before the reshoots. Sure, maybe it wasn’t working, but there is plenty of evidence to suggest the original script provided much better characterisation for at least Jyn and Bodhi. Also, the Saw Gerrera scenes from the reshoots are really messy. After they leave Jedha, the film gets much better and the finale is pretty great.
I agree, however, that making the reactor shaft an inside job was a bad call.