logo Sign In

Post #1396193

Author
Eyepainter
Parent topic
Star Wars Episode II: March of the Separatists (Released)(v2 a WIP)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1396193/action/topic#1396193
Date created
23-Dec-2020, 9:02 PM

theprion said:

Some interesting workarounds.

But since Jango isn’t on Geonosis in your cut, why not completely cut him from the film? He was always an useless fanservice of a character anyways.

Consider this: the kaminoans might have their gene pools or something like that. Why would they (or Count Dooku, for that matter) need a random mercenary to be either an outside asset or a loose end on this monumental operation? So Obi follows the dart trail to Kamino, discovers the clone army, and when he is about to meet the unknown “supervisor” who ordered the clones, a ship (still Slave I, but who cares) departs hastily upon learning of the jedi’s inquiry, but not before Obi whips him a tracking device. This should improve the veil of secrecy involving Count Dooku and the assassination plan when Obi-Wan finally uncovers him in Geonosis, rather than just skip leads from one bounty hunter to another. What do you think?

As for Shmi, I’m curious to see how you make it work. Paired with the downplaying of Jango, these are some promising changes I have no knowledge of prior attempts.

I’m not sure where I said that Jango wasn’t on Geonosis. All I said is that his purpose had been served once Obi-Wan followed him to Geonosis, which means that he still goes there.

I sympathize with the notion of getting rid of Jango in his entirety, though. It’s just that I couldn’t find a way to explain how Obi-Wan arrives on Geonosis without him following Jango there. Still, I’ll see if it’s possible to get rid of the Jango scenes from the arena. My only concern is that Mace Windu’s entrance might be needed. Having just a bunch of random jedi appear out of nowhere seems a little vague and hard to follow. But I’ll see if it works.