I don’t mean to be “impertinent”, just giving story reasons for my opinions. Yes, I can make my own cut, and might. I didn’t want to “rip off” Smudger’s idea, and wanted to be supportive of his project and do my best to help him make it the best it can be.
But I never claimed ownership of this cut. I thought it was a discussion forum where suggestions and feedback were welcome? I guess it’s not?
Yes, as I said before ideas and suggestions are always welcome and certainly helpful.
But (imo) not in that demanding tone.
I already noticed this in the other thread and I would like to say I do not like this way.That’s all.
Are you demanding I not be “demanding”? I’m confused, are you disrespectfully asking me to be more respectful?
I’m defending my opinions, I’m not demanding. I understand that Smudger is gonna do whatever he wants, but if people are gonna say something is a plot hole when it’s not, or that character development doesn’t matter, I’m gonna bring up a counterpoint. I don’t feel that’s out of line, especially as anything I say gets four people talking about how they disagree with me, but if I dare disagree with them I’m being “impertinent”?
I already pointed out that one of the recommendations (which was one I agree with) was fully shut down by Smudger and not going to happen. I don’t see how calling people names and making assumptions about their tone and intent is any more respectful though.