logo Sign In

Post #1385754

Author
Dantearant
Parent topic
The Rise of Skywalker: RESURGENCE (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1385754/action/topic#1385754
Date created
12-Nov-2020, 2:33 PM

Finished watching today, it’s a really good edit! I love the extra personality you’ve added to the Knights of Ren, they’re really cool now.

Ben’s journey feels more fleshed out due to the Knights of Ren and Corellia additions.

Eliminating Rey healing the snake was well done, wonder if the snake could be shown afraid in any way.

Framing Rey’s trip to Tattooine as something she’s doing with her friends is very well done.

I do miss the yellow saber at the end. I also wish we could have had more Ben after we last see him, wonder if there is any way of CGIing Adam Driver from elsewhere, maybe when Rey looks to the side (when she looks at the twin suns), we could cut to him smiling, maybe even a voice line from some other show / movie.

I dont know how you did Rey saying she killed parents, that was flawless. The flashback with the explosion was shocking! Really enjoyed seeing the story like this. Also holding Palps reveal for later worked nicely.

Only noticeable editing bit was a line from Kylo where the volume goes too high too quickly (“what you DID” i think the line was.

In summary, this is a near definitive version of TROS for me!

EDIT: Also, the changes to the Rey and Tie Fighter showdown are perfect. The buildup is fantastic.