logo Sign In

Post #1383268

Author
Chulk
Parent topic
Harry Potter Extended Editions (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1383268/action/topic#1383268
Date created
30-Oct-2020, 1:47 PM

JJPotter said:

It is what it is. I don’t see the video clips as spoilers. First, for fanedits, those that download them are supposed to own the source material. So those that get the edits should already own the movies. Without context, those clips should mean absolutely nothing to anyone that is watching the movies for the first time. I assume that no one watches trailers for movies then since those include spoilers. To me, that isn’t a valid argument.

But I’m not going to tick anyone off by ruining their experience of the movies. I’ll just leave the old intros on and be done with it. I wanted something special for the new releases, but that just isn’t what is wanted.

JJpotter,

I just went and watched the new intros and I have to say I’m impressed! I’m just a fan of the movies and love it when there’s more that can be done/added to bring a more comprehensive story to life…movies will never be able to incorporate every aspect of the books, but when they edit out parts of the story for the sake of screen time…my opinion is the movie loses something! I felt that way with the Lord of the Rings trilogy, The Hobbit trilogy, and then again when I watched the ABC family versions of the Harry Potter movies…it just changes the experience in my humble opinion! But you just do you and please keep me in mind when you finally release your fan edit! Thanks for what you’re doing!

Cheers!
Chulk