If your PS2 is stretching it vertically, what its really doing is NOT compressing it vertically. If your TV is 4:3 and your PS2 is set to 16:9, its set wrong. You want it set to 4:3, doesn't matter whether its letterbox or pan & scan since all that does is decide which version to default to if a dvd has both letterbox and pan & scan versions. Since no DVDs will bother cramming two videos on one disc these days, doesn't matter what its set to.
If your PS2 is stretching it vertically, what its really doing is NOT compressing it vertically. If your TV is 4:3 and your PS2 is set to 16:9, its set wrong. You want it set to 4:3, doesn't matter whether its letterbox or pan & scan since all that does is decide which version to default to if a dvd has both letterbox and pan & scan versions. Since no DVDs will bother cramming two videos on one disc these days, doesn't matter what its set to.