Okay the votes have died down, so here’s what we ended up with. I tracked all of the votes but I myself did not vote since I knew who everyone was and wouldn’t be unbiased. I’ve included the top three for each knight in this chart:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/13gq_LrOPef0JmLNW94ZSUPJSGiyus-rd9c1OeU8bRs4/edit?usp=sharing

I made a weighted score by awarding one point for being a voter’s first choice and a half point for being runner-up, but ultimately sorting by total votes yielded the same ranking. As you can see, I was in the top three for each, so I have an important question for everyone:

My plan was to create 2 fully produced voice packs for each Knight so that editors can have their final say in picking which of two voices they want for each Knight. Realistically, I can do two voices (like Kuruk and Vicrul) and have them sound different enough from each other, but the whole point of this was to get more voices in here so I wasn’t all the Knights. Given these top three (I’ve also included the votes mrbenjamino got for his alternate Ap’Lek submission), who does everyone think the two final voices for each Knight from that spreadsheet link?

I’m thinking this:

Ap’lek: krausfadr (#5) & mrbenjamino (#8)
Kuruk: Me (#8) & my wife (#5) - who was the only female voice we managed to get, but people seemed to like!
Ushar: poppasketti (#3) & mrbenjamino (#8)
Vicrul: Me (#8) & dgraham (#3)

And if we were to just pick one of each, I’d personally say:

#5
#5
#3
#8

When we’ve communally decided on two, I will reach out to those who will be the final voices about potentially re-doing a line or two so nothing feels out of place in the movie.

LASTLY! I plan to still include a couple extra “Traitor!” shouts from different people in the sound pack, so that might be a 5th voice.

Thanks so much for your help, everyone!