For me, personally, the latest Orchi ship scene works well. Looks good and pretty believable.

The Mustafar scene just still doesn’t work for me, personally. My eyes see, even without being told, is not real footage. Especially the troopers out in the open. Another factor that takes me out is while they are stark white in the BF2 footage, they are not during the Kylo shots. Plus that scene is in slow mo that still feels odd from going to a scene “regular” speed on the ground from a wide shot to a up close and slow.

I appreciate the hard work involved, but it still looks off. I still prefer an edit that takes out the Mustafar opening and opens with Kylo exiting the nebula that poppa did some time back.

Again, that’s just me!