I know this isn’t an entirely important edit, but in comparison to TFA and TLJ, Ahch-To in TROS feels very barren and lifeless (other than that one shot of the two porgs), there is always usually porgs far off in the distance making noise. Maybe adding in Porg noises in the distance would help it feel more like Ahch-To?
From what I remember, porgs weren’t in TFA at all. I had to add sound effects from TLJ for TFA closing shots to match. I think they were only invented to cover up the amount of noise due to the island being a bird sanctuary. Totally get what you mean about TROS Ahch-To.
You’d think wasting all that money going to Jordan to film on green screen that they’d at least wait til breeding season was over and reshoots on Ahch-To instead of filming in a studio. It REALLY show.