I don’t even want to imagine the pro Maclunkey arguments now. 😉
I personally have a soft spot for the arguments supporting Luke’s scream in Cloud City. One of us! One of us!
Ruining a silent sacrifice befitting a Jedi aside, it’s that it’s so obviously not Mark screaming. What thought process ended with Hey, let’s use an Emperor’s scream outtake and take an early lunch. Nobody will know!
Seriously though, how hard would it have been to get Mark Hamill in front of a mic and yell?
And they took it out for the next version anyway, how do the Flannelheads™ rationalize that reversion?