logo Sign In

Post #1337991

Author
InitAbsolute
Parent topic
Star Wars: The Phantom Menace - Faster, More Intense! (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1337991/action/topic#1337991
Date created
25-Apr-2020, 7:26 PM

Octorox said:

So for V1 of this edit, I went with opening titles that mirror the sequel trilogy approach (no 20th century fox logo or fanfare, new Lucasfilm Ltd. logo)

For V2, I’ve decided that I want to bring back the Fox fanfare, but I have a few options in terms of what direction to go:
-use the original Prequel-era Fox and Lucasfilm logos from the Blu-Ray
-use the Fox logo sans “A News Corporation Company” and new Lucasfilm logo from the 4K release
-Use the “updated” 2011+ Fox logo and new Lucasfilm logo from Adywan’s ESB Revisited

No matter which direction I go, I’m probably going to be taking out “A News Corporation Company”, but I’d appreciate everyone’s thoughts on the matter.

Use the 1994 Fox logo sans “A News Corporation Company” and the Lucasfilm logo from the Blu-ray.

The new Lucasfilm logo looks nice but looks really out of place when seen on pre-Disney films (also there’s a significant period of black due to the logo not being created with the Fox fanfare in mind).

I like Adywan’s Revisited approach though, but I’d like the logos to be more in line with the other edits, which is to keep them mostly intact.

-IA