The whole “re-edit the movie to how my (faulty) memory says it should have been all along” idea is intriguing for a fan edit. I would love to see an unedited video of the Rough Cut, even if it looks and sounds terrible and has lots of “scene missing” cards and stock footage or production stills and animatics from the storyboards. I may not agree with every editor’s choices, but I’m not going to say he shouldn’t make it if he really wants to… (even if it’s based on a movie I hated and think can’t be saved, which is not this movie). I would love to see a super cut of all the missing and alternate or deleted footage put back in, like a Star Wars motion scrapbook… not just like Deleted Magic but like a movie you can watch beginning to end.
Still, didn’t Adywan pump up the volume on the “twin setting suns” scene because that’s how he “always remembered it”? Nobody bashed him for that…