logo Sign In

Post #132744

Author
Wesyeed
Parent topic
Episode 3: Fan Editing Ideas Discussion
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/132744/action/topic#132744
Date created
22-Aug-2005, 6:12 PM
That sounds excellent. I'd love to actually see the dueling instead of a blur of motion with the occasional saber twirling. After the TPM duel with maul, I don't know what Lucas was thinking when he decided to edit this. He already got it right...

R2's hero moments getting the spotlight during a flippnig WAR! comes off out of place. Anakin smirking at the camera and saying han's lines for no better reason than to try to be like han solo is distracting. Redundancy, the whole part with the buzz droids, stupid, imagine jedi need droids to get rid of little floating robot things. come on.... R2 forgetting he has the power to cling to a ship's surface is stupid, setting aside what happens in esb since that's years away and maybe he wanted a swim...?

Dooku knowing or even caring who skywalker is without any indication that he'd ever would in the previous movie just seems stupid. lol, there's stupid all over this thing. cheerleader palpatine, etc... good lordy this will be a chore. good luck, editors. You're gonna need it...

I like the idea of grievous being a rebuilt Maul. It's just so incredibly stupid that these jedi knights, with the force as their ally, would just rather hack the stupid magna droids to pieces and waste their time when they could disarm them and throw them into a wall or whatever. look at what obi did in episode 1 as a padawan. One wave of his hand and three dumb droids flew off their feet. Unless they have shields I suppose they're defensless against force attacks.