There’s no reason there has to be peace for a thousand generations. Ben just says the Jedi were the guardians of peace in that time.
Palpatine in AOTC says the Republic has stood for a thousand years. Potentially a discrepancy between that and Ben’s line, but you could explain it. Either way neither of them says there was no war at all for that long.
Ah, nice. So going off that we could say:
The Jedi have stood for a thousand generations, acting as a separate religion, and when the Republic was formed they became their guardians of peace and justice. It makes sense for Ben to group the two together when explaining to a young boy with a limited attention span.
The Republic was founded one thousand years ago, and could have had all the major conflicts Disney wants to fill their story. Personally I’m very excited to explore this period.
Yeah. You could argue though that Ben’s says they were the guardians in the Old Republic, which implies that was there for a thousand generations too, but who cares. You could even just say there’s been multiple iterations of the Old Republic, like there was a new constitution a thousand years ago. Either way, I think it’s all ambiguous enough that they could pretty much do whatever they want.
Rewatching TCW, Pre Vizla says that the darksaber was stolen by his ancestors from the Jedi temple during the “fall of the Old Republic.”
https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Fall_of_the_Old_Republic
What that means for the High Republic, who’s to say, I guess there’s isn’t anything established. I think I’ve said it before but showing the Old Republic Jedi vs. the Mandalorians seems like such an obvious next step but what do I know. Maybe they’re saving it for later.