That’s what makes this decision to pursue the Emperor as the end goal (especially as it was executed) and to keep Leia in the story as the catalyst for Kylo’s turn so WEIRD. Just on its face that’s such a tiny eyehole to thread on a moving needle. Not saying you couldn’t do it - and maybe there’s a version of this story where they managed to build to that idea well, and maybe they actually tried to make Leia a legitimate character whose disassociated presence was actually felt. But both those decisions are SO deck-stacked against their successful execution I just don’t understand why they got pursued considering they knew how much time they had left to make and finish this thing.
They didn’t HAVE to choose this course of action.
I disagree that any of these movies have rendered any of the other films pointless, if only because the point of Star Wars has never really been in its plotting. The plotting is a means to get to the themes, and even the bad Star Wars movies are trying to say something, thematically, within their own runtimes. Sequels don’t nullify or make pointless their predecessors. But I think what this movie was trying to say for itself was so confused and honestly, kind of infantile - it’s just hard to get a good hold on what it wants to be AS a story.
I don’t know. I think just like The Return of the King, ROTJ was the natural end of the six part story. This just feels like too much of the same. There’s a part of me that wants to relive my childhood, have that feeling again, and there are moments in ROTS where I’m transported back to that time, but it’s fool’s gold. I’m tired of seeing the same thing over, and over, gushing over another pointless cameo, or another reference to the glories of the past. I have some hope, that Star Wars might flourish in a different medium, like tv for a while, but as far as the movies go, I’m done with it all. I’ve had my share of Jedi falling to the dark side, redemptions and what not. The Star Wars movie franchise is running in circles with diminished returns.