That is a good video, with a well reasoned articulated take I mostly agree with considering how large the fanbase really is. The only thing I dislike (and to the creator’s point this did start in fairness from the opposition itself and all those annoying overlong video essays) is when those who disliked TLJ are so quickly characterized as disagreeing with its themes. Can’t I just have plain not enjoyed the movie? Personally for me it’s not that the ideas were against my rigidly religious view of the force or Luke Skywalker, I thought the movie had groaner lines flat humor and awkward pacing, great performances with slick visuals but poorly packaged. I don’t rage over TLJ when I watch it I just get bored. I’m a movie fan way way before a Star Wars fan, I didn’t hate the movie for “doing wrong by my Star Wars” if anything I’ll be more forgiving, I didn’t enjoy the overall execution.

Of course that leaves less to talk about ad nauseam over 2 whole years like nerds can when disputing lore, so I can understand how it ended up over time becoming that as the main focus of discussion. Like the video creator states, nitpicking is sort of what that side of youtube is for. Nothing against this particular creator though who seems to have a good head on their shoulders about the whole thing.