I think Adywan pulled it off so well because so many could hop aboard the project… everyone wants to improve the OT’s graphics. They are great movies and to improve their look is something we all agree on.
But the PT? Can we decide what to do? How radical do we go, and how much would we like to keep? Would people work with a graphics update for a movie who’s story / cast aren’t really that good (at least compared to the OT)?
Despite my concerns, I would do my best to support such a daring project.