Rogue One - now we’re really getting to the good stuff.
[…]
Otherwise I love this movie and everything about it. I rank it behind only Star Wars and ESB among the theatrical films.
I also rank it behind the first two. But that’s not me saying much.
I absolutely loved R1 the first time I watched it; my initial rating was 9/10. But each subsequent viewing diminished my opinion; I now rank it 6/10, slightly above ROTJ and TFA — and that’s almost wholly due to the visuals and music, not the writing or characterization.