What people will notice and possibly get annoyed at is the presence of black bars on the sides -- even more so if they're not the same size.
I guess this was a reference to me using different size bars. No, I chucked that, the plan (sorta) as it stands is the 32 lines to both the left and right.
The question I've put to the group a few times now (though phrased differently): does ANYONE watch these DVD's on a video device that does not have overscan? If the answer is 'no', then no-one would ever see the presence of black bars (to the sides anyway) unless their TV is misaligned.
You're right, it never crossed my mind that everyone's capture is going to be with different devices with different size capture windows. Though I was assuming the Official DVD was played in a PC not captured so would be closest to the complete frame width.
What's stopping you from upsizing that to 720xX, since you were planning on resizing it anyway?
I guess this was a reference to me using different size bars. No, I chucked that, the plan (sorta) as it stands is the 32 lines to both the left and right.
The question I've put to the group a few times now (though phrased differently): does ANYONE watch these DVD's on a video device that does not have overscan? If the answer is 'no', then no-one would ever see the presence of black bars (to the sides anyway) unless their TV is misaligned.
You're right, it never crossed my mind that everyone's capture is going to be with different devices with different size capture windows. Though I was assuming the Official DVD was played in a PC not captured so would be closest to the complete frame width.
What's stopping you from upsizing that to 720xX, since you were planning on resizing it anyway?
Huh?