act on instinct said:
- Making the style not clash with the material, making a bad pan&scan.
Don’t take me wrong, but for me about half of your examples (2, 4, 6, 8, 9) look cropped.
The framing looks off, with the interest points too close to the edge of the frame.
No, this is more than fair! George especially makes so much use of the whole frame end to end which will present a tough challenge, I actually have plans to really get in and rotoscope specific shots and some may be split and squeezed, the 4th shot you’re referring to is actually squeezed with very little cropped from the original frame. All said I’m working on a teaser to show how the project might look, I do understand it’s going to be too cropped for some people who have no interest in a new aspect ratio, but as I’m using it for my own shortcuts to rearrange scenes and dialogue I don’t see right now how I could continue with wide.