I was asked by a few other members and a mod to start a thread that focused on the FAN reviews of the "Fan" created DVD sets.
The main goal here is to post PERSONAL reviews (NOT attacks) of the MANY fan created transfers of our beloved films so please try to keep the reviews to the discussion of the video’s strengths and weaknesses and also do your best to provide details to support your praise or criticism of the release and In order to keep a consistent look to these reviews please try to follow either one of these basic outlines.
“5-Star” Type Review
TRANSFER TITLE: The DVD’s name
REVIEW: Your review should include your overall opinion of the quality of the DVD’s video and audio presentation quality i.e. if the video looks washed out, pixilated, displays compression/motion artifacts or if the audio sounds hollow, tinny, brassy or over modulated. You can also discuss what you expected from the DVD or did not expect.
VIDEO RATING: *** (You can use “? of 5” Stars to rate the video and audio)
AUDIO RATING: ****
VIEWING EQUIPMENT: Here you should list all of your equipment by brands, model numbers and display type (connection types if you wish)
OR use a…
Ty“Top-Ten” Type Review
(Starting with what you consider the “not so great” transfers then lead up (or down
) to the best)10 - (Enter Transfers name here)
The enter a review of the film under the releases title
9 - (Enter Transfers name here)
And then countdown to your personal #1
Have fun and Enjoy the show!