SomethingStarWarsRelated said:

[MikeWW said:]

In theory sure, but compare TFA to ANH.
George’s version of “faster more intense” works, whereas JJ’s results in cringily overplayed scenes like Finn and Poe’s “good to meet you too” scene.

On a related note, Oscar Isaac is really really bad in TFA. It’s like he didn’t know his character.
He either overplays it or under plays it. In the Trench run he seems bored.

I would say all of that is subjective. I liked the “good to meet you too” scene. And I think Oscar Isaac is good in the film.

The dialogue in the scene is really bad and overlong and the actors seemed under the influence of some kind of stimulant.