logo Sign In

Post #1281969

Author
Valheru_84
Parent topic
Star Wars: Remastered - A New Special Edition (* unfinished project *)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1281969/action/topic#1281969
Date created
17-May-2019, 9:04 PM

Just chiming in to say that I love your work Petrovelly but I have to agree with everyone regarding the opening Tantive scene. The pacing of how the scene unfolds in sync with the music is perfect and key to it’s effectiveness in the feelings it generates, setting the stage for the entire OT saga.

So being that it is your fan edit, I think you’ve already reached the crossroads where you need to decide ultimately what you’re trying to achieve (a graphically modernised version of the theatrical OR a modern take on the original that will take you on a slightly alternate journey) and what is more important to you (making yourself happy or the community happy with which you hope to share the edit with).

Ultimately it’s all your choice but it would help contributors a lot I think to clarify exactly what you’re aiming for and how people may help you get there. Your OP already does this but it feels like you’re already deviating from it somewhat and I can feel some light tug of war already going on with people explaining what could be better with the scene in respect to your original goals and yourself trying to explain how it’s actually what you want to do and how you see it as a good change but I think it’s at odds with what people are expecting.

Anyway, just my 2c and keep up the great work!