Originally posted by: Darth Editous

Is it supposed to have fallen just as Luke walked in front of it?

Yup, that's what's meant to happen, although hopefully people won't come to the conclusion that it just fell off, because with any luck they won't notice it at all.

Unfortunately it never worked for me, I actually find it the most distracting edit (but that is mostly because the others are sooo good!). It was the only case where I thought the problem was less of a distraction than the fix, especially since the cloak ends up back on the wall in following shots.

Actually, just looking at the original again, I guess it is pretty jarring since it is the same angle, just closer. I think it would be a case of had the edit not been mentioned here most would not have noticed it and it would have worked fine. Hehe, that's the problem with both wanting to make an invisible change and wanting people to know what you did!

In the end I guess we just have to explain it away as Ben's Magic Hut, since all his other ornaments appear, disappear and move around the room (most notibly on his centre table)!