logo Sign In

Post #1272369

Author
DominicCobb
Parent topic
Episode IX: The Rise Of Skywalker - Discussion * SPOILER THREAD *
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1272369/action/topic#1272369
Date created
5-Mar-2019, 12:11 AM

OutboundFlight said:

While I do see their message about Rey being a nobody (especially following the PT which foolishly made Anakin the “chosen one”), I for one never got the impression that Luke was somehow privileged. He just wanted to be like his father.

Don’t disagree.

Ben I could see being privileged, but I’d like to see them play it up more. Maybe even in an Excalibur like sequence where he tries to unlock an ancient heirloom of the skywalkers but fails- while Rey is deemed worthy of it not for her lineage but for morals.

In a way, depending on how you look at it, they already did a subtle version of this in TFA when Rey grabs the saber. But I get the desire for something explicit.

Maybe it is just my expectations subverted, but I would prefer to see Ben properly end the saga. His death would mark a true conclusion, rather than it being “the Skywalkers are all gone but Rey has founded the New New Jedi and all will be well for 30 years”. Most that comes down to how they present the ending.

I think there’s a lot of ways that they could make it work. I don’t think Ben has to die. I personally don’t want them to tie off the saga with a nice bow.

In my mind the ST is basically about how perfectly tied up happy endings are improbable. Would be pretty annoying to see them walk that back. (but again, there are a lot of ways that could manifest)