- Time
- Post link
I know, right? I don’t think there’s any better than the R1s for that right now, is there? (Since that series was kind-of a dud, although wasn’t it Michie Tomizawa’s first major role?)
There actually is a R2 Japanese DVD release of Southern Cross (which has been long out of print so you’ll have to get it second hand from somewhere like Yahoo Japan Auctions) but I’m not sure how the quality on the Japanese DVD version compares to the ADV R1 release, personally I’d assume the Japanese release would be slightly better since the Japanese DVDs probably use the original 16mm film negatives for their source as opposed to the nth generation copies ADV had to work with, that and the fact that Japanese companies usually tend to put forth a great effort to try and make high quality releases, I’ve actually been wanting to get my hands on the R2 release for a while now to see how the two versions compare I just haven’t had the money to get it (I may be getting a job soon so that may not be an issue for much longer).
sadly that is incorrect, the JP dvd set is worse than the adv set, chroma bleed, nigh noise levels, basicly taken straight rom the broadcast masters (or degraded copies atleast) the ADV set attempted to fix them but overall ruined them, removing most colors, leaving mostly heavy blacks and blue tones throughout the episodes, ive attempted to color correct the ADV set but it simpily cant be done, and the japanese rellease will cost you arround 500$
Like I said previously I didn’t know what the quality of the R2 DVDs were like and just assumed it would be better since it was a domestic release in the country of the shows origin, who knows in the right hands it might actually be somewhat salvageable and turn out to be better than the R1, highly unlikely but you never know, I’d actually like to see a good comparison shot between the two DVD releases to see what the differences are.
sorry for the late response
https://imgur.com/XO4rl0U
id say the japanese set is the better quality, sharper image, and could be corrected
Hmm looking at the 2 side by side as is and I think I’d prefer the slightly smoother look of the ADV set just a tad bit more than the Japanese release (it just looks a tad more pleasing to the eye IMO, not to mention the fact that from what I’m seeing there appears to be more of the image in the ADV set, and based on a few tests I’ve done, that might actually be the case although I’ll have to investigate further, could you post full screenshots of both releases instead of a half and half screenshot for a more accurate comparison between the two?), however when it comes to retaining the color information I’d definitely go with the Japanese set in a heartbeat because it looks like more of the original color information is retained in the Japanese release, whereas the ADV set appears to have altered the colors to the point where there’s severe crushed blacks and whites in comparison, it’s pretty much a pick your poison kind of deal in this case and it’s really hard to say which release is actually better because they both have their pros and cons.
