logo Sign In

Post #125709

Author
DarthAstuart
Parent topic
Director's Cut?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/125709/action/topic#125709
Date created
27-Jul-2005, 9:04 AM
i guess if i'm being totally honest, any time a filmmaker releases a "director's cut" that eliminates a theatrical cut I love, it bothers me a little. that's why I saved my Star Trek II original DVD to own alongside the two-disc "director's cut"--i love that movie and want all the versions I can get of it.

since I care so much about the star wars movies and the SE changes bother me more and more as time goes on, I guess I'm just more passionate about owning the original versions of those films. i like T2 and Aliens well enough, to use your example, but not owning the original cuts doesn't outrage me as much because I'm not nearly as attached to them.

plus, i can't think of another filmmaker who has undertaken the systematic and total deletion of his original works as Lucas has. releasing a director's cut on DVD is one thing--lucas' process (the SE re-release in 97, his many announcements that these are the definitive versions of the films while almost backhandedly slamming the originals, even further changes to the 2004 DVD release, few to no existing prints of the originals as seen on release) is a different animal.