as for questioning lucas with venom and spite, i didn't come to this thread to do that--i'm honestly interested in discussing him as a director and solely that. i do have plenty of venom and spite for him, because i think the prequels are mostly horrible movies that demonstrate lazy filmmaking, great hubris, and a mysterious lack of ability on Lucas' part. that doesn't have much to do with this discussion for me, though--like I said, a bad movie doesn't necessarily have to be poorly directed. in fact, my biggest gripes with the prequels probably have more to do with story and plot.
another directing choice I liked quite a lot--those faux handheld camera shots in the geonosis battle in AOTC. clever stuff, very visceral.