I will give you that it looks better… But I don’t think it quite hit’s the same mark as shifting the Hues to bring it more in line with other shots we see that are not so badly affected.

It’s things like this shot that destroy trust completely, trust in what the print displays come to a low point. That is not to say I don’t think you did a bad job of trying to tackle the issue but you did not go far enough.

It’s like a medical surgeon, our perception of a surgeon is someone that is quite careful which is true, but the reality can be very different that in order to do their job they pull people about and have to be quite rough with something to fix a major problem. Out come the Hammers and Saws to fix some things and it’s not so clinical but quite a rough and brutal process.

My process always starts out Brutal and then I reign it back in until I find the right amount of Brutal or how Brutal I should be. You said before that I over do it, which is correct, I do until I reign it back in to about the right amount.

In terms of the whole Binary Sunset I think perhaps Jabbas Palace from ROTJ might hold some answers for us.

This may mean the glow is that yellowish color and the Bottom of the sky is more Magenta which would make sense almost inverted.

If we followed this image as a guide we probably would end up with something in between the Red and the Purple Version rather than 2 very different looking versions.

So Yavin is actually Tattooine tinted more Red / Orange and Kashykk from the Holiday special was the same planet tinted green 😃