logo Sign In

Post #124270

Author
Gaffer Tape
Parent topic
Harry Potter *Spoilers* (Serious Discussions Only, No Flaming)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/124270/action/topic#124270
Date created
19-Jul-2005, 9:14 PM
Yeah, I can see how they'd follow Harry, but it still doesn't seem to me they'd wrap this up very well if Hogwarts was entirely out of the picture. And maybe I'm just a nerd like that, but I would be thinking, "They were so close! They need to finish school!" I guess I should have felt the same way about Fred and George, but, to be honest, they really didn't need school. And maybe Ron doesn't either (although he should be figuring out career plans by now), but Harry's dream is to become an auror, and(I'm laboring under the assumption that Harry is going to survive the series) his N.E.W.T.s are going to be important for his future career.

And that's a good Percy analysis as well, the Slytherin-esque behavior you mentioned. I never saw it like that before. To be honest, I always liked Percy in the first four books (I mean, he was especially helpful in the first book if not the friendliest soul, and you can understand his ambition up to that point) and, therefore, I really hope that he will do something to redeem himself by the end of the series. I was slightly disappointed by his one-line appearance in this book, but maybe it's for the best as I don't want to become any more annoyed with him.

Speaking of the Slytherins, though, does it ever annoy anybody besides me that every Slytherin (with the exceptions of Nigellus and Slughorn) seems to be a complete asshole? I mean, I can see understand that bad witches and wizards end up going through Slytherin house with the whole power above everything emphasis, but having every Slytherin be a bullying, bigoted, insulting villain just seems a little too... obvious. "Hmm, how about we put all the good people in these three houses, and then we'll put all the people who suck over here?" If it's that obvious that Slytherin=bad, wouldn't it just make sense to disband the house rather than train them up to wage war against the good guys? No wonder there'll all so bitter. I would be too if I was put in the house where I'm expected to be an ass.