logo Sign In

Post #1240297

Author
BiggsFan44
Parent topic
Star Wars as a cohesive universe/canon.
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1240297/action/topic#1240297
Date created
14-Sep-2018, 8:16 PM

DominicCobb said:

BiggsFan44 said:

RogueLeader said:
I just think you are at the point of thought that this a terrible movie even though there is still a lot to love about this film. Like others have said, I feel like you made this thread to find people to agree with your opinions rather than be open-minded about anything else.

Again, it’s not even about quality.
Let’s use Anakin instead of TFA since you people get hung up on defending JJ- how can early TCW Anakin, who is basically

  1. A different character than movie Anakin
  2. Clearly Filoni’s response to failings he perceived with movie Anakin

be said to exist in the same story as an alternate version of that character?
How can different be the same?

You know Lucas was heavily involved in TCW, especially in the early years right?

I do, although I was under the impression that he become more involved as it went along, since Gilroy and co say season one was a little more “just them”, and Filoni talks about how GL started to become excited about the potential around season 3.
That also explains why TCW Anakin became more and more like Hayden’s portrayal as the show continued, in both character and appearance (visually, they shaved down his chiseled-by-god-himself jaw and gave him Hayden’s slighty forward shoulders).
I also know that GL often gave in to Filoni, like with the Order 66 chip.