I don’t know. I haven’t seen it in so long but the scene where Anakin is alone in the council chamber and Padme is at their apartment and they stare out of their windows is probably the best scene of the whole PT. I know that in a lot of ways that’s a low bar, but I think it’s great and I’m being serious when I say that that scene is as well done as anything in the OT.
It’s actually better than most of the OT.
Let’s not get ahead of ourselves. No scene can be truly great without solid context to back it up.
That is a good sequence. And not a CGI creature in sight.
No dialogue in the script either.
Unfortunately Palpatine has an unnecessary VO that kills it.
JEDIT: beat by snooker
The only bad part of that scene is the added V.O of Palpatine.
Unpopular opinion:
Battle of the Heroes is a fine song, but it’s too bombastic and out of tone for the scene it’s in.
I agree completely.