Alrighty, here’s a new version with some sizing and color / lighting adjustments to the first BB-8 shot, as well as the deleted scene added (1st post updated):
https://vimeo.com/282740204 (password: fanedit)

Keep in mind, the rotoscoping of BB-8 itself is still rough. I want to see if the compositing can work with lighting, scale, and positioning before I go ahead and rotoscope properly in After Effects (or mocha).

Jarbear, with the deleted scene, I actually think the lack of reflective lighting and debris in the first and last shot is what stands out to me. There’s fire and explosions everywhere around them and it doesn’t seem to reflect that in the cockpit scenes. Although, I suppose everything exploding might all be behind them? The side panels don’t bother me much, though.