Hey Hal I FINALLY watched your edit with some friends the other night. The good thing was, they did not catch anything that looks out of place or couldn’t remember what was in the original cut. (It’s been awhile since the saw it.) The edit they did notice was the the Snoke Betrayal scene. I loved it, so much better than the theatrical!

Anyway, back to it. I loved the trimming up of the movie all in general. It cleaned up such unncessary “bulk” and toned down the overly comedic areas that were not necessary.

One of your big highlights i think is the moving of the Yoda scene for me. It makes a clean transition from the second Act to the final one.

All in all, you make good conservative choices to make the movie very enjoyable. So far the personal choice I would like to make a major edit is the Leia Poppins - mostly for visual reasons since the scene still makes me cringe on how … odd it looks and feels.

If someone was really good with CGI and could add BB-8 running with Rose and Finn to the shuttle … that would fix the goffy AT-ST scene … the Phasma battle isn’t as necessary for Finn’s character as much as his sacrifice scene…

Anyway, again Hal, amazing work!