Besides which, Kurtz and Kershner have their fair share of clunkers in their repertoire as well. there's no guarantee Jedi would have been magic once again simply because they're Kurtz and Kershner.
And Kurtz didn't LEAVE to do Dark Crystal. Kurtz was told they weren't going to use him for Jedi, due to his inability to keep the budget down and the movie on schedule, and he then went for and got the Dark Crystal job--a movie which also finished considerably overbudget and late, if I remember right.