This thread seems to get bumped all the time… so again as a sidebump, I might as well link the newest update on the “Luke throwing the lightsaber” scene with new music:
It works better, the previous version was just non sense. Making the angry walking away just a normal walking away is the best idea (if you wish to accomodate with other changes made to Luke though, so I’m not sure it would work in the context of TLJ:Legendary), as well as removing the weird back and forth of Rey from the shore to the center of the island. I even feel the voice-over is not necessary (or just put a voice-over from TFA).
(so if you want to use it in TLJ:L, the angry walking needs to be reinstalled and the added voice-over needs to stay out)
Too bad Ivan decided to go away, his edit seems to be on a better track now (especially since the corrections made to this particular moment have all been discussed here… anyway, that’s is choice).
(and +1 with the music choice, a far better idea than the twin theme and it even makes sense here)