I saw Hal’s edits only after the Force Awakens came out but during The Last Jedi, I as well did some editing during the cringiest parts. For example, after the opening scene I found myself already thinking “Yeah sorry… that has to go. Hal has some long nights ahead of him.” Haha! But not to the point that it ruined the first time viewing.
Maybe it’s also a little testament to what we think of your skills, Hal. 😉