Not scientific, I did an informal side by side comparison of the EditDroid and the Original TR47 ANH disks. In short, on whole both disks are equal in quality.

- PQ - the EditDroid set is slightly sharper, but you can only tell on freeze frame. With picture in motion, it's difficult to tell the difference.

The TR47 set is brighter (looks nice), but the shadowy areas are just a little washed out - very subtle.

- AUDIO - The TR47 set sounds nicer, but I think the original audio track is louder than on the EditDroid set.

- FEATURES: The only one I noticed because I don't dig into extras that much is that the EditDroid set has menus.

- MY SYSTEM: (Not the greatest in the world, but nice for the money)

MONITOR: Panasonic 50 in. PHD-6UY
DVD PLAYER: Toshiba SD-6200
RECEIVER: Pioneer VSX-D711
SPEAKERS: 5 ch. SpeakerCraft in Ceiling AIM-3's
SUB: SpeakerCraft 12 in. Sub