logo Sign In

Post #1220108

Author
Nate D
Parent topic
4k77 - shot by shot color grading (a WIP)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1220108/action/topic#1220108
Date created
26-Jun-2018, 1:54 AM

The Leia interrogation shots look wonderful, Dre, as does the new Antilles interrogation. I realize I am at a disadvantage seeing the shots static as apposed to live action and thus my shared thoughts may not necessarily be accurate to what is actually the case. My photography requires me to have my screen properly calibrated, so I do trust what I’m seeing to a degree.

Upon a second examination of your June 14th base grade compared to your newest base grade above, I do recognize the slight pinkish cast you mentioned in the original and do see the wisdom in removing it. And I do agree with your sentiments on NeverarGreat’s technicolor grade compared to your base grade—yours is indeed warmer and less green.

A few thoughts if I may:

What do you think about the screenshot comparison in the link below? It compares your June 14th base grade with your new June 25th base grade. Does it seem to you that the darkest parts of Vader’s costume and the shadows on him are perhaps too dark/black? I can’t seem to see the detail in the shadows of his costume quite as well as I can in your June 14th grade. Also, you may notice in the last shot of Leia holding her blaster that she seems to be darker in the new grade compared to your former grade. Again, I might be wrong since I’m not seeing these shots in live action, but what do you think? Many thanks!

Set 2: http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/115775
Set 1: http://screenshotcomparison.com/comparison/115776